The new NYC pied a terre tax is a landmine for landlords
Earlier this year NYC implemented a new tax on homes with an estimated value over $5 million that are non-primary residences (the pied-a-terre tax). For homes that qualify, the annual pied tax bill starts at around $40,000/yr and tops out at 1.3% of market value for houses and townhomes, and 6.5% for apartments. An important provision includes rented homes where the renter claims a primary residence located outside of NYC. The tax is on the property, not the occupants, so landlords will be stuck with the tax liability by default.
Header Image: 220 Central Park South: The most expensive home in NYC was purchased for around $238 million. However, the current DOF market value is around $15.5 million. This would put the projected pied tax bill at around $1 million per year. This is on top of the annual property tax, around $858,000 currently.
The tax is assessed based on the status of the apartment on January 5th. So before the landlord is aware that their renter is claiming primary residence outside of NYC, the renter might move out, and weeks or months later the landlord could receive a “surprise” pied tax bill. Whether the landlord is cash flow positive is not taken into account, and whether the outgoing renter claimed NYC residency prior to January 5th is not a determining factor.
As a result, it is imperative that the landlord or landlord’s representatives ask whether the renter will claim primary or non-primary residence, and who will be responsible for the pied tax bill if it is assessed. The Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) has created a pied-a-terre tax rider for this purpose. REBNY is a trade association that provides industry standard leases and riders.
Cooperative buildings may find that they are responsible for allocating the tax to the appropriate shareholder. As a result, some buildings may pre-emptively ban pied-a-terre buyers and renters going forward.
Landlords can appeal, either by proving the property was exempt, or challenging the valuation of the property to reduce or eliminate the liability altogether.
At a glance the number of properties that would be valued at over $5 million and are available to rent would represent only a small slice of New York City rentals. However, the ripple effects of the law could affect how pied-a-terre renters are received across the city, and could discourage pied-a-terre renters going forward. In addition, confusion over how the law was implemented has led to postponements and lawsuits, and could continue to sow confusion across the city.
SUMMARY: • The new NYC pied-a-terre tax applies to rentals • The mechanics of the law and its initial implementation have created widespread confusion • Liability defaults to the landlord unless a rider is added to the lease • Landlords can appeal but only up to a certain deadline • Landlords in co-op and condo buildings may run into bans or restrictions on pied-a-terre occupants